Rosemary and Rue
Seanan McGuire
Mary Robinette Kowal (Narrator)
Revealing a long agenda
I always have an audiobook to listen to while I walk or drive, etc. Usually these are books I have read in the semi-old-fashioned way, as black words on white pages. Typically I choose to listen to long series that were favorites when I read them. Thus I just listened to Seanan McGuire's Rosemary and Rue.
One of the great pleasures of restarting a favorite series is rediscovering just how good it is. Rosemary and Rue is the first novel in McGuire's October Daye.series. It is also McGuire's debut novel. At twenty novels (plus any number of short stories and novellas), October Daye is McGuire's longest series. It is also, in my judgment, her best. (I admit, though, that the most recently published October Daye novels are putting that judgment under strain.) October Daye is a perennial finalist for the Best Series Hugo. I hope it eventually wins,
Rosemary and Rue introduces us to October Daye, Toby, as she calls herself, is a changeling -- that is, a person who has both fay and human ancestors. (This, by the way, is different from the meaning of "changeling" in most European folklore.) She is estranged from both her father (human) and her mother (fay). She lives in San Francisco. She was married and had a child, but she is estranged from them as well. She has, in the past, earned a living as a private investigator, but her license lapsed and she now works at the checkout counter in a grocery store.
She receives a distress call from Evening Winterrose, one of the most prominent fay in the San Francisco Bay Area. The phone message records Evening's murder, and her call for Toby to find her murderer. Good way to start the action! It never lets up after that. Toby is in continual danger and often near death throughout.
The thing that struck me on this re-read is how carefully it plants the seeds for the story to come in the subsequent books of the series. We meet many characters who will become important to Toby in the future. With the benefit of having read the rest of the series, I can see that even at this time, McGuire already knew the shape of the books to come.
The audiobook is narrated by Mary Robinette Kowal, and she does very well. Her voice for the Luidaeg -- the Sea-Witch. is perfect. She is just as grating as I had always imagined her, but at the same time sounds chillingly dangerous. I was not thrilled with her Tybalt (the King of Cats in San Francisco). But Tybalt is a prominent character in the later series -- it was almost inevitable that my imagination would give him an internal voice that would conflict with any other reader's version.


